The AI Disagreement Index
Where AI models
actually disagree.
Every full council run on Synero is independently graded for cross-model consensus: where GPT, Claude, Gemini, and Grok agreed, where they split, and which chair dissented. This index tracks the aggregates.
239
Councils graded
Full multi-model runs analyzed
74/100
Average consensus
100 = full substantive agreement
71%
Runs with a clear dissenter
One model departed from the group
Which chair dissents most?
Each advisor chair carries a distinct reasoning style; dissent is counted when a chair clearly departed from the rest of the council.
Consensus by council tier
| Tier | Avg consensus | Councils |
|---|---|---|
| Unlabeled | 72/100 | 127 |
| Balanced council | 79/100 | 77 |
| Fast council | 75/100 | 16 |
| Flagship council | 79/100 | 12 |
| Custom council | 62/100 | 7 |
Methodology
After a full council run completes (two or more advisors plus a synthesis), an independent grader model reads every response and scores substantive agreement from 0 to 100, lists unanimous points and contested topics, and identifies a dissenting chair when one clearly departed from the group. Individual questions and answers are never published here: this page shows aggregates only. Shared councils display their own per-run consensus certificate, published explicitly by the person who ran them.
See the disagreement on your own question
Run a council, get a consensus certificate, share it as proof.